Question 1

Is a best-before date legally required?

Accepted Answer

It depends where you sell. In the United States, date labelling is not federally required on most foods and the terms are not defined in regulation, which is why "Sell By" drifted into consumer use it was never designed for. Infant formula is the notable exception and has its own mandatory requirements. In the EU and UK the distinction is legally defined. In Canada a durable life date is required for products with a durable life of 90 days or less, in the prescribed bilingual format. Whatever the term, the date and the storage condition belong together on the pack: a best-before date without "Store below 25C" is a number with no claim behind it.

Question 2

What is the difference between "Use by" and "Best before"?

Accepted Answer

Best before is a quality statement: after it the product may be past its best but is not necessarily unsafe. Use by implies a safety limit and should be reserved for products where that is actually true. In the EU and UK this distinction is legally defined, with Use by required for microbiologically highly perishable foods, and the two are not interchangeable. In the US neither term is defined in regulation, and FDA supports "Best if Used By" for quality. Choosing Use by when you mean quality commits you to a safety claim you may not be able to support.

Question 3

When do I need a process authority rather than a calculator?

Accepted Answer

When your product is both low-acid and high-moisture. Water activity above roughly 0.85 combined with a pH above roughly 4.6 is the combination that supports growth and toxin production, and a product in that range is generally either a low-acid canned food or an acidified food. Both require a scheduled process established by a qualified process authority, plus registration and process filing with FDA. That is not a determination to make from any calculator, ours included. Salsas, sauces, pickled vegetables and infused oils are the products that most often surprise their makers here.

Question 4

How accurate is a calculated shelf life?

Accepted Answer

It is a starting point for a study, not a substitute for one. A defensible date comes from storing the product under its intended conditions and pulling samples on a schedule, testing microbiological, chemical and sensory measures at each point. Shelf life is the last point at which every measure is still acceptable, and you then apply a safety margin, commonly 20 to 30%, because your storage is controlled and a distributor warehouse is not. Accelerated studies at elevated temperature give a faster first estimate but are unreliable wherever heat changes the failure mode: fats oxidise differently, emulsions break, and crystallisation behaves nothing like it does at ambient.

Question 5

Does water activity matter more than pH?

Accepted Answer

Neither on its own. They work as a pair, which is why the safety question is a matrix rather than a single number. Either a low enough water activity or a low enough pH can make a product shelf stable; it is the combination of high moisture and low acidity that needs a thermal process or refrigeration. Water activity is also not the same thing as moisture content: it measures the water that is actually available to microorganisms, which is why a high-sugar product can be wet and still stable. And re-test after any formulation or supplier change, since a new supplier ingredient can move water activity enough to matter.

Shelf-Life Calculator

Check your own jurisdiction

Read more

Shelf-Life Calculator

Other tools

Check your own jurisdiction

Read more